Note that this has been for the last 3 or 4 seasons, how the Colts always played.
During the season they play great and are super overhyped. But, the Colts always botch it up during the playoffs.
Right now their record and Peyton Mannnings QB rating means squat. I won't believe they will make it to the Super Bowl until they get there. Even then not sure if they will win. 4 years ago the Titans came in as a wildcard pic after that "Music City Miricle" and made it all the way to the Super Bowl aginst the Rams which is one of the most Memoriable Super Bowls in the past decade or so.
I think the Colts will be put out again in the playoff finals, probally by a team they had no business loosing to.